Customer found blade in chips from Chester takeaway

Published date: 01 March 2013 |
Published by: Jim Green
Read more articles by Jim Green


 

A CHINESE takeaway owner from Chester has been prosecuted after a customer found a dangerous metal blade in a portion of chips.

Yue Qin Sie, of Acres Lane, Upton, admitted selling chips classed as unfit and unsafe for human consumption.

Cheshire West and Chester Council (CWaC) prosecuted both Sie, 50, and her company Yummy Trading following a complaint to environmental health staff.

Ian Moore, prosecuting for the council, said a customer bought the chips from Venue Fish Bar in Ellesmere Port which Sie owned.

“In essence, a fish and chip shop sold a portion of chips which contained a broken blade from the chip cutting machine,” he said.

West Cheshire Magistrates Court heard the customer went to the takeaway in Chester Road, Whitby, to buy an evening meal for his family on March 19, 2012.

Having bought some Chinese meals and a portion of chips, he returned home.
“The chips were going to be shared by his son and his son’s girlfriend,” said Mr Moore.

“They emptied the Chinese food on their plates using a large spoon and they divided the chips between them using their fingers.”

Mr Moore said the couple went upstairs to eat and were halfway through their meals when the girl noticed “something shiny” sticking out of a chip.

“At first she thought it was a piece of mirror or glass but then realised it was a metal blade,” he said.

Mr Moore said the pair were “shocked” and binned the rest of the food, keeping the blade to show the council’s environmental health service.

Two environmental health officers visited the takeaway on March 22 as part of the investigation and decided the business should be closed down due to the serious nature of the allegation.

Mr Moore said Sie signed a voluntary closure notice and the takeaway was allowed to reopen the next day following another inspection.

Interviewed with the help of an interpreter in April, Sie admitted suspecting something was wrong when the chips being cut were bigger than normal.

She said staff searched the shop in an attempt to track the blade down once they knew the blade was missing.

“They did not find the blade and continued serving regardless,” said Mr Moore.
David Farley, defending, said Sie had run the takeaway since 1993 without any problems.

He admitted the blade was “potentially nasty” and Sie understood she had made a mistake in not closing once the blade went missing.

“They should have closed,” he said.

“It is a big step for them to close their business for the night. They did everything they thought they could at the time.”

Mr Farley said two inexperienced members of staff had been working on the night in question and did not realise the blade had fallen off.

CWaC – whose investigation totalled 31 hours – asked the court for costs amounting to £4,740 which Mr Farley said was “excessive”.

Magistrates told Sie she was fortunate nobody was hurt and the consequences could have been much worse.

Sie and Yummy Trading were each fined £500 and ordered to pay £500 costs and a £15 victim surcharge.

Speaking after the hearing, Cllr Lynn Riley, executive member for community and environment, said: “This incident was a very serious offence under food safety legislation and had the potential to cause serious injury to a member of the public.

“Officers from the council’s food safety team investigated and discovered that the owners showed a total disregard for food safety legislation by not taking the appropriate action to avoid this incident from occurring.

“CWaC take these matters very seriously. The general public have a right to expect that the food they buy is safe to eat.”

 

Local Business Offers & Promotions

  • Free Family Law Drop In

    Free Family Law drop in service every Thursday between 9am-12pm, providing a no strings attached 15 minute consultation with a Family Law Specialist.

    Valid Until: Friday, 11 Apr 2014

    Voucher Code: Every Thursday 9-12

    Terms: Please call 01244 312166 to book an appointment with Family Law secretary Lesley Jones.

  • Don't get caught out this winter!

    Swansway Accident Repair Centre, Wrexham will honour a minimum £50 insurance excess contribution for any vehicle repaire required by Swansway, Wrexham from no until the 31st December 2013.

    Valid Until: Tuesday, 31 Dec 2013

    Print
  • People’s Market

    Wrexham Town Centre Stalls ranging from 21 sq.m / 230 sq.ft to 53 sq.m / 571 sq.ft The ground floor of the People’s Market comprises two glazed atrium entrances off Chester Street housing a number of shops and leading into the main market hall. This houses 55 individual market stalls, 29 of which line the perimeter and 26 of which comprise island stalls. Businesses within the market complex include confectioners, clothing retailers; perfumes and cosmetics; Welsh shop; second hand furniture retailer; optician and music and nostalgia retailer. A car park is situated above the ground floor market area, which provides 450 car parking spaces. Attractive incentives and concessionary rents are currently being offered to new traders, whether a new business start-up or an established market trader new to the area. Concessionary rents are made available during the initial twelve months of occupation.

    Valid Until: Friday, 07 Mar 2014

    Terms: Terms & Conditions Tenure Occupation of the property will be by way of the Council’s standard Periodic Business Tenancy Agreement. Alternatives to the Standard Periodic Business Tenancy Agreement are also available to allow prospective tenants flexibility when looking to occupy the market when either relocating or starting a new business. Rent Ranging from £284.93 to £575.58 per calendar month exclusive payable monthly in advance by direct debit. Service Charge Ranging from £117.93 to £293.19 per month exclusive payable monthly in advance by direct debit. Service charge is in respect of charges incurred by the Landlord in providing services to the common parts of the market. This is subject to a review on the 1 April of each year. Business Rates The tenant will be responsible for the payment of business rates. Details are available directly from the Business Rates department on 01978 292030. Advice on the availability of Small Business Rates Relief will also be availabl

  • Wheatsheaf Workshops

    Wheatsheaf Workshops comprise of a variety of accommodation in a well established two storey complex, ideal for small business use. They are located in a quiet area on the outskirts of Wrexham within close proximity of the Aqueduct World Heritage site at Froncysyllte. The Workshops are approximately 8 miles south west of Wrexham Town Centre, with good communications via the A483 providing excellent access to the national motorway network. Key Features of the Property • On-site parking • Fire & security alarm • Mobile patrolled security • ICT and Telephone links

    Valid Until: Friday, 07 Mar 2014

    Terms: Terms & Conditions Tenure Occupation of the property will be by way of the Council’s standard Periodic Business Tenancy. Rent Ranging from £420.00 to £2,600.00 per annum exclusive + VAT payable monthly in advance by direct debit. Service Charge Ranging from £198.61 to £882.69 per annum exclusive + VAT payable monthly in advance by direct debit. Service charge is in respect of charges incurred by the Landlord in providing various services at the estate. In this instance; exterior and communal area repair & maintenance, water, cleaning of communal areas, security charges & waste removal. Business Rates The tenant will be responsible for the payment of business rates. Details are available directly from the Business Rates department on 01978 292030. Insurance The Council will insure the building for its full reinstatement cost against damage by fire and/or specified perils and the tenant will be re-charged directly on an annual basis. The tenant will be responsible for in

  • £10 SPA VOUCHER

    £10 voucher towards use of our exclusive new luxury spa facilities.

    Valid Until: Sunday, 30 Jun 2013

    Terms: Can not be redeemed for cash. Expires 30th June, 2013. One voucher per person. Not to be used in conjuction with any other offer.

    Print
  • ONE DAY FOOTBALL SESSION FREE

    One day free football coaching session when you intruduce a friend.

    Valid Until: Friday, 30 Aug 2013

    Terms: All sessions held at Monkmoor Recreation Ground, Shrewsbury.

    Print
  • Car Of The Week

    03 03 LAND ROVER FREELANDER TD4 SERENGETI 5 door in maroon metallic with only 28,444 miles, full service history, one local owner, in fantastic condition, new tyres, CD plater, air con £4995

    Valid Until: Wednesday, 04 Sep 2013

  • Long Established Company

    We are a professional company who won't let you down. Call us for more details

    Valid Until: Wednesday, 04 Sep 2013

    Print
  • 25% Off Ink Cartirdges

    25% off Ink Cartidges on production of advert only.

    Valid Until: Wednesday, 31 Jul 2013

    Terms: Not to be used in conjunction with any other offer. Offer ends 31st July, 2013

    Print
  • £50 off completion of first job

    £50 off completion of first job plus £30 Voucher of customer's choice on completion of recommendation work

    Valid Until: Sunday, 30 Jun 2013

    Terms: Tems and Conditions Apply

    Print

View all offers & promotions

Featured Businesses

View all adverts